In my experience, there are certainly good and bad test-takers. Some people are more comfortable demonstrating their knowledge on a test, while others get overly-stressed and then forget everything they've learned. The best way that I can think of to accommodate all types of test takers would be to have a variety of questions and formats included in one test. For those who write best, have an short essay portion. For those who know the grammar best, have a couple questions that focus on that aspect. Along the same lines, it would also be fair to include a listening and oral part to every test to accommodate the students who excel in this portion. However, this would quickly become an extreme amount of work for the teacher, both during and outside of class, and would be extremely impractical. Because this ideal balance is simply not practical, I think tests can be slightly biased toward those who do better on written and reading segments.
I happen to be a very good test taker most of the time. I tend to do better on more objectively scored exams and worse on test that place more emphasis on essays. My ideas are not always well focused and concise, which can make answering an essay question quite difficult.
I'm not really sure what can be done to either make tests more student-friendly or to train students to be better test takers. Some might suggest that students should practice what they're worst at in an effort to improve, but I've learned that that may only make them resent it more and have it become ever more frustrating and tiresome for them.
I agree 100% that tests should include different varieties of materials and styles. Do you think that there should be an essay, multiple choice or matching, and oral components all administered on the same day or maybe through out the week? I also think that the teacher should provide a positive environment that will help ease the student's anxiety.
ReplyDeleteI never thought about adding a portion for listening and oral performance to tests! Admittedly, it would be extra work, but now that I think of it, in all my high school FL finals, there was a section where we had to listen and another section where we had to speak. Hmm.... I wonder how much work it would take or if there are other sources out there with pre-created all encompassing tests.
ReplyDeleteI know for my German classes now and when I had first started in Spanish, my teachers play a recorded track off a CD and we either had to copy down what we heard like a dictation, or answer questions based on the audio to check our listening and comprehension.
ReplyDeleteI also have a hard time coming up with a solution to the negative relationship between students and exams, but everyone is different and if it was easy to solve, then it probably already would be! I wish I could just say that bad test takers need to study more, but if testing simply isn't their strong suit, no amount of studying will help overcome it. Making the exams as well-rounded as possible is the only way to fairly test all types of students.
ReplyDelete