I think homework is appropriate for a foreign language
class. The ideal situation would be to
have everyone in the class have a language tutor to assist with homework and
practice conversation. However, since
this is not a possibility I think that students in language classes should be
assigned a language partner, a classmate in their class, in order for them to be
more productive doing homework. I can
see the value in doing tedious conjugation worksheets and practicing writing
new words by writing these new words in sentences, etc. In my opinion, this kind of homework does
have a place, but the best homework assignments should be done in pairs so that
both students will have the opportunity to speak to each other and learn
together.
Growing up a person did not
learn his/her native language on his own, it was a community-learning
experience. A child learns his native
language from everyone around them, but it is hard to replicate this in a
foreign language classroom where we do not have this advantage. This is the main reason studying in a foreign
country and spending time abroad is so important for someone who really wants
to learn the language. A preschooler
doesn’t know that much of his native language, but can easily be instructed in
English, for example, because he already has a basic subconscious understanding
of how English works, English comes second nature to him. By the time he is in preschool he should be
able to understand it and speak it without difficulty. The work comes in teaching this child how to
read and write in his native language.
From this comparison I want to
point out the fact that it seems “backwards” to expect first-year language
students to write and read in their new foreign language without having any
real ability to understand or speak in that language. Homework can play a role in filling this
obvious gap, by making students memorize vocabulary, listen to simple conversations
and practice the basic structure of that new language. I think homework can be improperly used when
it doesn’t engage the student and is only given as “busy” work, instead of the
teacher having a goal in mind when assigning that homework. I think some homework should be assigned
before the lesson in order to familiarize the student with the new language
concepts and that way they might be able to use these new words and language
structures in class during the lesson.
The homework assigned before the class should be pretty simple and straightforward
and the homework given after class should just be used to reinforce the lesson,
thus forcing the student to use what they have learned.
I think that
the 6 tips that the video gave were valid ones that I have heard before. Finding a dedicated place to study, clear of
distractions is very important and making sure that it is well-light. Eating snacks while studying does help me
sometimes and I don’t mind having music playing in the background. My sister always did her homework while
watching TV, I could do that but not when I was working on a reading assignment. I whole-heartedly agree with turning off the
cell-phone (or at least turning the sound off) and also signing out of Facebook
for example. One girl I’m tutoring actually
hides her cell-phone while she’s studying.
Taking notes while reading is a useful tip, but I like reading it
through one time without stopping and then rereading if needed to take notes. Taking notes while reading does help, but it
makes reading take a lot longer which is a downside. I try to take breaks and that way assignments
don’t seem so long or time-consuming. The
video was entertaining and the study/hw tips it gave were good ones, but when
it comes down to it students should do what works best for them.
I really like your idea of a language partner from within the class. But a question: should the partners be at the same level or should someone struggling in the class be paired with someone who understands the material and can "bring up" the other person?
ReplyDeleteWhile I can see what you mean when you said that it seems backwards to expect new L2 learners to read and write in a language they don't understand, this seems a contradictory stance to what you later mentioned when you said that you think students should do simple assignments on a new concept prior to the classroom explanation. Will reading something they don't understand really help them the next day, or should they be practicing the few things that they have been taught, even if they get most of it wrong?
ReplyDelete